Posts about ethics

Merck and Elsevier Publish Phony Peer-Review Journal

Elsevier is one of those publishers fighting open science. They try to claim that the government publishing government funded research in an open way will tarnish science. The argument makes no sense to me. Here is another crazy action on their part: they published a “journal” funded by Merck to promote Merck products. Merck Makes Phony Peer-Review Journal:

Merck cooked up a phony, but real sounding, peer reviewed journal and published favorably looking data for its products in them. Merck paid Elsevier to publish such a tome, which neither appears in MEDLINE or has a website, according to The Scientist.

What’s sad is that I’m sure many a primary care physician was given literature from Merck that said, “As published in Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine, Fosamax outperforms all other medications….” Said doctor, or even the average researcher wouldn’t know that the journal is bogus. In fact, knowing that the journal is published by Elsevier gives it credibility!

As I have said the journals fighting open science should have their credibility questioned. They are putting their outdated business model above science. We should not see organizations that are focused on closing science research through deceptive publicity efforts and lobbying efforts as credible.

Related: From Ghost Writing to Ghost Management in Medical JournalsMerck Faked a Research JournalMedical Study Integrity (or Lack Thereof)The Future of Scholarly PublicationFresh questions raised about prominent cardiologist’s role in “ghostwritten” 2001 meta-analysis of Vioxx trialsScience Commons: Making Scientific Research Re-usefulPublishers Continue to Fight Open Access to ScienceMisleading or Deceptive ConductPeter Suber Response to Rep. Conyers

  • Recent Comments:

    • Anonymous: The Link the Feynman videos seems to be working both with IE and FF, provided you have the...
    • Justin Hunter: Very cool illustration of mistake proofing! But as you suggest, it could be further improved...
    • Anonymous: I grew up around hummingbirds, and there’s simply nothing like watching them buzz around...
    • James Bly: The statement that most tires are landfilled is not accurate and has not been true for at least...
    • Anonymous: Crows also pass the so called „mirror test“ which is used to test self awareness in animals. To...
    • modi: Interesting post. What matters in the end is that the diet you choose is something you can sustain...
    • Patrick: Thanks for reminding me about this match. I wonder if chess will ever be as popular again as it...
    • Jonathan Winter: Here is a good article on advantages and disadvantages of Geothermal for the home. This is...
  • Recent Trackbacks:

  • Links